The Pope may question President Javier Milei’s economics, but the results speak for themselves

Pope Leo XIV went to Argentina last week. It was the first papal visit to this country in almost four decades, following Pope John Paul II’s apostolic journey to Uruguay, Chile and Argentina between March 31 and April 12, 1987.

Some may wonder why Pope Francis, who was born and raised in Buenos Aires, never visited the country of his birth in an official capacity. It was reportedly under consideration, according to The Irish Times contributor Tom Hennigan on April 22, 2025, but his difficult relations with political leaders convinced him that “any visit home would risk him being dragged into the minefield of Argentina’s increasingly toxic politics.” Current Argentine president Javier Milei also infamously called him an “imbecile,” “communist turd,” “representative of evil” and a “piece of shit,” among other things.

Milei eventually made peace with Pope Francis. He visited the Vatican on Feb. 11, 2024, when the pontiff canonized the first female Argentine saint, María Antonia de Paz y Figueroa, and they reportedly had a “very good and very friendly” private meeting. Milei even formally invited the Holy Father to visit Argentina.

That invitation was ultimately accepted by Pope Leo XIV. He visited Buenos Aires, Córdoba and Luján between Nov. 8 and 11. He was well received at every location by the large Catholic population and others. The pontiff also met Milei at the nation’s capital. It was a positive and friendly get-together, by all accounts.

At the same time, Pope Leo XIV decided to engage in a discussion that could have led to some frosty moments.

“The economy must serve the person, not the person the economy,” he said in his first public address in Argentina. While the Holy Father acknowledged his support for an economic agenda that “stimulates private initiative,” he also spoke in favour of policies that would help and benefit “the unemployed, retirees and all those who, despite hard work, nonetheless struggle to meet their household’s needs.”

The fact that Pope Leo XIV engaged in this conversation wasn’t completely surprising. Popes throughout history have expressed their opinions in encyclicals and elsewhere, including speaking out against the influence of free markets and the private sector. Pope Francis made this argument on numerous occasions, which obviously fit with his Jesuit education and disenchantment with the excesses of laissez-faire capitalism. While Pope Leo XIV isn’t as left-wing as his direct predecessor, he clearly has his own opinions about whether the free market economy and Roman Catholic Church teachings can be compatible.

What’s striking about this statement is that Pope Leo XIV chose to say it while visiting Argentina and Milei.

The Argentine president is one of the biggest free-market champions of any political leader currently in power. He’s also a strong supporter of the libertarian philosophy of anarcho-capitalism, largely devised by U.S. economist Murray Rothbard, that rejects concepts like statism and socialism. Milei has promoted free markets, private enterprise, and open trade  and firmly believes it will lead to economic success for individuals, families and businesses alike.

It’s worked rather well in Argentina, too.

“As of September, the economy is growing at 5 per cent on a yearly basis,” the Cato Institute’s Marcos Falcone wrote in December 2025. “Poverty, which exceeded 40 percent before Milei took office and peaked at 52.9 percent in the first half of 2024, is now down to 31.6 percent. Monthly inflation, which often surpassed 10 percent in the pre-Milei era and reached 25 percent in December 2023, now hovers around 2 percent. Both exports and imports are rising rapidly.”

Milei’s party, La Libertad Avanza, won almost 41 per cent of the vote in the October 2025 midterm elections. They now have 13 of 24 Senate seats, and 64 of the 127 contested lower-house seats. If an election were held today in Argentina, there’s little question that the president and his party would remain in power.

No one in Argentina, including Milei, opted to speak out against Pope Leo XIV. He was a guest in their country, was afforded a public platform and expressed his opinion in a thoughtful manner. You can agree or disagree with what he said, but at least it was done in an honest, forthright and non-confrontational manner.

Pope Leo XIV’s position may be admirable, but it’s not realistic if you support the principles of greater economic freedom and more private sector influence in a democratic society. I’ve always strongly supported the position that the person must serve the economy. This is the opposite of what the Bishop of Rome believes. Many pro-free-market Catholic politicians, academics and thinkers have also taken a different point of view and successfully navigated these waters for decades.

When it comes to the question of which came first, the person or the economy, there can be differences of opinion and a civilized discussion. Milei obviously disagreed with Pope Leo XIV, but he’s learned that strong leadership doesn’t always require him to make an official statement or public spectacle of himself. Live and let live has evidently become his personal motto.

Michael Taube is a political commentator, Troy Media syndicated columnist and former speechwriter for Prime Minister Stephen Harper. He holds a master’s degree in comparative politics from the London School of Economics, lending academic rigour to his political insights.

Explore more on Economic freedom, Capitalism, Poverty


The views, opinions, and positions expressed by our columnists and contributors are solely their own and do not necessarily reflect those of our publication.

© Troy Media

Troy Media empowers Canadian community news outlets by providing independent, insightful analysis and commentary. Our mission is to support local media in helping Canadians stay informed and engaged by delivering reliable content that strengthens community connections and deepens understanding across the country.